| Species | Name Used in Reference |
|---|---|
| Peprilus medius (Peters, 1869) | Peprilus medius (p. 1623) |
| Peprilus ovatus Horn, 1970 | Peprilus ovatus (p. 1642) |
| Peprilus simillimus (Ayres, 1860) | Peprilus simillimus (p. 1624) |
| Peprilus snyderi Gilbert & Starks, 1904 | Peprilus snyderi (p. 1624) |